Peer Review Process

SciNusa: Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities adopts an Open Peer Review model to enhance transparency, accountability, and trust in the scholarly publication process. This model is implemented based on the following principles:

  1. Transparency of Reviewer Identities
    Reviewer identities are disclosed to authors to promote accountability and encourage constructive feedback throughout the manuscript evaluation process.

  2. Open Review Reports
    Peer review reports are made publicly available alongside published articles, allowing readers to understand the scholarly evaluation process and assess the strengths and weaknesses identified by reviewers.

  3. Interactive Review Process
    Authors and reviewers are permitted to communicate openly during the review process to encourage academic collaboration and improve manuscript quality.

  4. Reviewer Recognition
    Reviewers are given the option to sign their review reports and receive public acknowledgment for their contributions to the peer review process.

  5. Ethical Standards
    All parties involved in the review process are expected to adhere to established ethical guidelines to ensure fairness, professionalism, mutual respect, and freedom from bias.

The implementation of the Open Peer Review model aims to strengthen transparency, accountability, and the overall quality of scholarly manuscript evaluation for the benefit of authors, reviewers, and the wider academic community.

Key Features of Open Peer Review in This Journal

  • Reviewer identities are disclosed to authors.

  • Peer review reports are published alongside accepted and published articles.

  • Authors and reviewers are allowed to communicate directly during the review process.

  • Reviewers may choose to sign their reports and receive public recognition for their contributions.

  • The review process upholds the principles of publication ethics, fairness, and academic integrity.

  • Editorial decisions and their justifications are communicated transparently to authors.


Peer Review Process Stages

  1. Submission and Technical Screening
    Upon submission, each manuscript undergoes an initial technical assessment to ensure compliance with the journal's formatting requirements, submission guidelines, and publication ethics standards.

  2. Initial Editorial Assessment
    The editorial team evaluates the manuscript to determine its suitability, academic relevance, and alignment with the journal's aims and scope.

  3. Editor Assignment
    Manuscripts that pass the initial editorial assessment are assigned to an editor responsible for coordinating and managing the peer review process.

  4. Reviewer Selection
    The assigned editor identifies and invites reviewers with relevant academic expertise to evaluate the submitted manuscript. At least two reviewers are appointed for each manuscript.

  5. Peer Review Evaluation
    Reviewers conduct a comprehensive assessment of the manuscript, focusing on its academic quality, methodological validity, originality, relevance, and scholarly contribution.

  6. Author Revision
    Based on the reviewers' comments and recommendations, authors may be required to revise their manuscripts. Depending on the extent of the required improvements, the revision process may involve several rounds until the manuscript meets the journal's publication standards.

  7. Final Editorial Decision
    The editor makes the final publication decision by considering the reviewers' recommendations and the authors' responses to the requested revisions. The possible decisions include:

    • Accept without Revision: The manuscript is accepted for publication in its submitted form.

    • Accept with Minor Revisions: The manuscript is accepted subject to minor corrections or improvements within the specified timeframe.

    • Major Revisions Required: The manuscript may be accepted provided that substantial revisions are made in accordance with the reviewers' and editor's recommendations.

    • Resubmit for Further Consideration (Conditional Rejection): The manuscript is not accepted at this stage but may be reconsidered following substantial revisions and a new evaluation.

    • Reject: The manuscript is declined and will not proceed to publication.

  8. Publication
    Manuscripts that receive final acceptance proceed to the publication stage, which includes final copyediting, layout preparation, proofreading, and online publication on the journal's website.


Plagiarism Policy

All manuscripts submitted to SciNusa: Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities are subject to plagiarism screening using Turnitin software to ensure the originality and integrity of scholarly work.

The journal establishes a maximum similarity index of 25% for submitted manuscripts. Manuscripts exceeding this threshold may be returned to authors for revision or rejected, depending on the nature and extent of the similarities identified.

Authors are responsible for ensuring that their manuscripts are original, properly cited, and free from plagiarism. All sources, quotations, and references must be appropriately acknowledged in accordance with the journal's referencing guidelines.

The similarity index is used as an initial screening indicator and does not automatically determine whether plagiarism has occurred. The editorial team retains the authority to assess the similarity report and make the final decision based on academic integrity and publication ethics.