Generative AI Policies
Generative AI Policies
SciNusa: JOURNAL OF SOCIAL SCIENCES AND HUMANITIES • EDITORIAL & PUBLICATION ETHICS
Artificial Intelligence (AI) Policy
Responsible Use, Transparency, Confidentiality, and Human Accountability
SciNusa: Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities recognizes the growing role of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in supporting academic research, scholarly communication, social science investigations, humanities research, and manuscript preparation. AI technologies may provide valuable assistance in organizing research materials, analyzing information, improving language, and supporting academic writing. However, the journal also acknowledges potential risks, including inaccurate or fabricated information, undisclosed AI-generated content, algorithmic bias, plagiarism, copyright infringement, breaches of confidentiality, and the misuse or manipulation of research data.
This policy establishes ethical requirements and responsibilities for authors, editors, Editorial Board members, peer reviewers, and publishing personnel involved in the scholarly publication process. It is intended to maintain academic integrity, research originality, transparency, and accountability throughout all stages of manuscript preparation, submission, evaluation, and publication.
This policy complements the journal's existing Publication Ethics, Authorship Criteria, Peer Review Process, Reviewer Guidelines, Conflict of Interest Policy, Plagiarism Policy, and Research Misconduct Policy.
Core Principle
Artificial Intelligence may support scholarly activities but must never replace human intellectual contributions, independent scientific judgment, editorial responsibility, or academic accountability.
All individuals involved in the publication process remain fully responsible for the accuracy, originality, integrity, and ethical standards of their respective contributions. The journal applies specific requirements to authors, editors, and reviewers according to their roles and responsibilities.
1. Purpose, Scope, and Definitions
For the purposes of this policy, AI-assisted tools refer to artificial intelligence technologies, including generative AI systems, large language models (LLMs), machine learning applications, and other automated technologies capable of generating, modifying, analyzing, or transforming text, images, audio, video, computer code, datasets, and other forms of scholarly content.
This policy applies to the use of AI technologies in research activities, manuscript preparation, editorial management, peer review, and publication processes.
Routine spelling, punctuation, and basic grammar-checking tools that do not generate or substantially modify scholarly content are distinguished from generative AI applications. However, any AI tool that materially generates, rewrites, summarizes, develops arguments, interprets information, or influences research findings must be appropriately disclosed.
The use of AI as a research subject, analytical instrument, or methodological approach is not prohibited. Studies involving machine learning, deep learning, predictive analytics, computational social science, digital humanities, AI-based public services, and technology-supported social research are welcome, provided that their methodologies, data sources, analytical procedures, and validation processes are clearly explained and comply with established scientific and ethical standards.
2. Responsible Use of AI by Authors
Authors may use AI-assisted technologies to support their scholarly activities, provided that such use is transparent, responsible, methodologically appropriate, and consistent with applicable research ethics and intellectual property regulations.
Acceptable supporting activities may include organizing research ideas, improving language clarity, assisting with data processing, developing computer code, identifying potentially relevant literature, and supporting preliminary analytical activities. Nevertheless, authors must independently evaluate and verify all AI-assisted outputs before incorporating them into their manuscripts.
The following requirements apply:
-
Human Responsibility: All authors remain fully responsible for the originality, validity, accuracy, reliability, and integrity of their submitted manuscripts. AI systems must not be listed as authors or co-authors because they cannot assume academic responsibility or accountability for published research.
-
Verification of Information and References: Authors must independently verify all references, quotations, facts, statistical information, research findings, theoretical interpretations, and AI-generated outputs. Fabricated references, inaccurate citations, misleading information, and unverifiable sources are strictly unacceptable.
-
Intellectual Contribution: Research questions, theoretical arguments, critical discussions, interpretations, and conclusions must represent the authors' own intellectual contributions and scholarly judgment. AI-generated material must not be presented as independently established scientific evidence.
-
Transparency and Disclosure: Authors must disclose substantive use of generative AI or AI-assisted technologies during manuscript preparation. The disclosure must clearly explain the tools used and the purposes for which they were employed.
-
Research Ethics and Intellectual Property: Authors must respect copyright, licensing requirements, participant consent, confidentiality, personal data protection, and applicable research ethics standards when using AI technologies.
-
Originality of Manuscripts: AI-assisted writing must not be used to conceal plagiarism, reproduce copyrighted material without authorization, fabricate research findings, or misrepresent the originality of scholarly contributions.
The journal emphasizes that AI-assisted writing does not transfer academic responsibility from authors to technology providers. Authors remain accountable for every statement, argument, reference, and conclusion included in their manuscripts.
3. AI Use Disclosure and Manuscript Declarations
Authors are required to disclose any substantive use of generative AI or AI-assisted technologies during manuscript preparation.
The disclosure should include the following information:
-
The name of the AI tool or service used, including its version where available.
-
The specific purpose of using the AI technology.
-
The tasks performed with AI assistance.
-
The relevant manuscript sections affected by AI assistance, where applicable.
-
The verification, evaluation, and revision procedures undertaken by the authors.
The corresponding author is responsible for providing an accurate AI-use declaration during manuscript submission and updating the declaration whenever the use of AI changes during the revision process.
The final declaration must be included in the published article under the heading Declaration of AI and AI-Assisted Technologies, preferably before the References section.
Authors who have not used generative AI for substantive manuscript preparation are encouraged to include a statement confirming such non-use.
Example A — AI Used During Manuscript Preparation
During the preparation of this manuscript, the authors used [name of AI tool/service and version] for [specific purpose, such as language improvement, organization of ideas, or writing assistance] in [relevant manuscript section(s)]. All AI-assisted content was critically reviewed, verified, and revised by the authors. The authors take full responsibility for the accuracy, originality, and integrity of the final manuscript.
Example B — No Substantive Generative AI Use
The authors declare that no generative AI tools were used to produce or substantively revise the content of this manuscript. Any routine spelling, grammar, or punctuation checks did not alter the scholarly content of the work.
Example C — AI Used as Part of the Research Methodology
This study employed [name of AI model/tool, provider, and version] to conduct [specific research activity or analytical procedure]. The model configuration, data sources, input parameters, research procedures, and validation methods are described in the Methods section. The authors remain fully responsible for the accuracy, reproducibility, and interpretation of the research findings.
When AI is used both as a research instrument and as a manuscript preparation tool, authors must provide both relevant disclosures. All declarations must accurately represent the actual use of AI throughout the research and publication process.
4. AI-Generated Figures, Images, Data, and Code
The use of AI-generated or AI-assisted figures, illustrations, images, tables, datasets, and computer code must comply with academic integrity, transparency, and intellectual property requirements.
Authors must ensure that AI-generated materials are scientifically appropriate, accurate, relevant to the research objectives, and not misleading to readers.
The following provisions apply:
-
AI-generated illustrations, diagrams, and images included in manuscripts must be appropriately disclosed when relevant, and authors must ensure that they possess the necessary rights and permissions for publication.
-
Synthetic data and AI-generated research materials must be clearly identified and distinguished from actual empirical observations, field data, interviews, surveys, and experimental results.
-
AI-assisted statistical analysis, programming, data processing, and computational procedures must be sufficiently documented to enable critical assessment and, where feasible, research reproducibility.
-
Authors must not manipulate, fabricate, falsify, or selectively modify research images, photographs, statistical charts, or empirical observations using AI technologies in ways that misrepresent the original research findings.
-
AI-generated content must not be presented as authentic historical documents, cultural artifacts, interview transcripts, participant statements, or field observations without clear identification and appropriate methodological justification.
The journal reserves the right to request original research materials, supporting datasets, or additional methodological explanations whenever concerns arise regarding the authenticity or reliability of AI-assisted content.
5. Use of AI by Editors and Editorial Personnel
Editors, Editorial Board members, and editorial personnel must exercise professional judgment and maintain academic independence when handling submitted manuscripts.
AI-assisted technologies may only be used for limited and appropriate administrative or technical purposes that do not compromise editorial confidentiality, impartiality, or the integrity of publication decisions.
The following requirements apply:
-
Editorial Independence: Editors must not delegate final editorial decisions, scholarly assessments, or substantive manuscript evaluations to generative AI systems. Decisions regarding acceptance, revision, or rejection must be based on independent editorial judgment and relevant reviewer recommendations.
-
Confidentiality: Editors and editorial personnel must not upload unpublished manuscripts, confidential research data, reviewer reports, author information, or private editorial communications to public or unauthorized AI applications.
-
Administrative Assistance: AI-assisted tools may be considered for non-confidential administrative activities, provided that their use is appropriately authorized and subject to human supervision.
-
Integrity and Verification: Editors remain responsible for evaluating any information generated by automated systems and ensuring that editorial actions are fair, accurate, and consistent with the journal's publication ethics.
-
Transparency: Any substantive use of AI by the journal or publisher in editorial and publication workflows must be appropriately communicated to relevant parties.
The use of AI by editors must remain consistent with the journal's Open Peer Review policy, Publication Ethics, Conflict of Interest Policy, and Research Misconduct Policy.
6. Prohibition of AI Use by Peer Reviewers
Mandatory Peer Review Confidentiality and Independence
Peer reviewers are required to conduct manuscript evaluations independently using their own academic expertise, professional experience, and scholarly judgment.
Reviewers are prohibited from using generative AI or AI-assisted applications to evaluate, analyze, interpret, summarize, or formulate substantive assessments of submitted manuscripts.
This prohibition is intended to protect the confidentiality of unpublished research, maintain independent academic evaluation, and prevent the inappropriate delegation of scholarly judgment to automated systems.
Peer reviewers must not:
-
Use AI applications to read, summarize, interpret, analyze, or evaluate submitted manuscripts.
-
Use generative AI to prepare, rewrite, or substantially modify peer review reports, critical comments, methodological assessments, or recommendations to the editor.
-
Upload, copy, transfer, or disclose unpublished manuscripts, manuscript excerpts, figures, tables, datasets, supplementary materials, or confidential editorial communications to public or unauthorized AI platforms.
-
Delegate any part of the scientific evaluation, assessment, or editorial recommendation to AI systems or unauthorized third parties.
-
Use AI-generated judgments as a substitute for their own independent academic expertise.
Because SciNusa applies an Open Peer Review model, reviewer identities and review reports are disclosed in accordance with the journal's peer review policy. Nevertheless, reviewers must respect the confidentiality of unpublished research materials and must not disclose manuscript content outside the authorized review and publication process.
Reviewers who cannot complete an evaluation independently must inform the handling editor and decline the review assignment.
All review reports, recommendations, and scholarly evaluations must reflect the reviewer's own intellectual contribution and professional judgment.
7. Confidentiality, Privacy, and Research Data Protection
SciNusa recognizes the importance of confidentiality and responsible data management, particularly in research involving individuals, communities, institutions, and social organizations.
Authors, editors, and reviewers must exercise particular care when handling sensitive or confidential information, including:
-
Personal information and identifiable participant data.
-
Student, teacher, lecturer, and educational institution records.
-
Interview transcripts, survey responses, and field research documentation.
-
Social, cultural, political, and community-related research materials.
-
Institutional performance reports and organizational documents.
-
Public health information and other sensitive research datasets.
-
Unpublished manuscripts and confidential editorial correspondence.
Authors must not submit identifiable participant information, confidential institutional records, or third-party copyrighted materials to AI services without appropriate authorization and compliance with applicable legal, ethical, and data protection requirements.
Editors and reviewers must preserve the confidentiality of all unpublished submissions and editorial communications, regardless of whether the journal applies an open or closed peer review model.
The use of publicly available AI applications does not eliminate obligations relating to informed consent, confidentiality, copyright, research ethics, and personal data protection.
8. Non-Compliance, Editorial Assessment, and Corrective Actions
SciNusa takes violations of its AI policy seriously. Any suspected misuse of AI, undisclosed AI-generated content, fabricated references, manipulated research materials, breaches of confidentiality, or other forms of academic misconduct will be assessed by the editorial team.
When credible concerns arise, the journal may request explanations, original research data, supporting documentation, methodological clarification, or additional evidence from the authors or other parties involved.
AI-detection scores and automated similarity reports must not be regarded as conclusive evidence of misconduct or used as the sole basis for rejecting manuscripts or imposing sanctions. All findings must be evaluated carefully through a fair, evidence-based editorial assessment.
Depending on the seriousness and nature of the violation, the journal may take the following actions:
-
Request clarification or additional disclosure regarding AI use.
-
Require authors to revise or correct AI-assisted content.
-
Request additional methodological information or original research materials.
-
Require further independent assessment of the manuscript.
-
Reject a manuscript that violates the journal's publication ethics.
-
Publish a correction or expression of concern when necessary.
-
Retract a published article when serious violations of academic integrity are established.
All corrective actions will be conducted in accordance with the journal's Publication Ethics and Research Misconduct policies, ensuring fairness, transparency, and appropriate opportunities for the parties concerned to respond.
9. Policy Implementation and Related Information
This Generative AI Policy applies to all activities related to manuscript preparation, submission, editorial assessment, peer review, manuscript revision, and publication in SciNusa: Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities.
All authors, editors, Editorial Board members, peer reviewers, and publishing personnel are expected to understand and comply with the provisions of this policy.
This policy should be read together with the journal's other editorial and publication ethics policies, including Publication Ethics, Authorship Criteria, Peer Review Process, Reviewer Guidelines, Plagiarism Policy, Conflict of Interest Policy, and Research Misconduct Policy.
SciNusa is committed to continuously reviewing and updating this policy in response to developments in artificial intelligence technologies, scholarly publishing practices, and international research ethics standards.
Through this policy, SciNusa reaffirms its commitment to academic integrity, responsible innovation, transparency, and the preservation of human intellectual contributions in scholarly publishing.




