Generative AI Policies

Ar-Ruhul Ilmi: Journal of Islamic Education and Islamic Thought

1. Introduction

Ar-Ruhul Ilmi: Journal of Islamic Education and Islamic Thought recognizes the growing role of Generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) and AI-assisted technologies in academic research, scholarly writing, and scientific publishing. These technologies may support various academic activities, including language improvement, literature exploration, data organization, translation, and manuscript preparation.

However, the journal emphasizes that the use of Generative AI must be conducted responsibly, transparently, and ethically. AI technologies must not replace human intellectual contributions, critical thinking, scholarly judgment, or academic responsibility.

This policy establishes guidelines for authors, editors, and peer reviewers regarding the appropriate use of Generative AI throughout the journal's publication process. It aims to safeguard academic integrity, research originality, intellectual responsibility, and the credibility of scholarly publications, particularly in the fields of Islamic education, Islamic thought, Qur'anic and Hadith studies, Islamic philosophy, and contemporary Islamic studies.

2. Definition and Scope of Generative AI

Generative AI refers to artificial intelligence technologies capable of generating or modifying content, including text, images, tables, data, computer code, and other forms of digital material based on user instructions or prompts.

Examples include, but are not limited to:

  • ChatGPT and other large language models (LLMs).

  • Google Gemini and Microsoft Copilot.

  • AI-assisted writing, translation, paraphrasing, and editing tools.

  • AI-based image, audio, and video generation applications.

  • Other AI technologies used to support academic research and scholarly communication.

This policy applies to all manuscripts submitted to, reviewed by, or published in Ar-Ruhul Ilmi: Journal of Islamic Education and Islamic Thought.

3. Policy for Authors

Authors are permitted to use Generative AI and AI-assisted technologies to support their research and manuscript preparation, provided that such use complies with the following requirements.

a. Responsible Use of AI

  • AI tools may be used to improve grammar, spelling, language clarity, translation, and readability.

  • AI may assist in organizing ideas, structuring manuscripts, and identifying relevant research topics.

  • AI-generated suggestions must be critically evaluated and verified by the authors.

  • Authors must ensure that all information, references, quotations, interpretations, and research findings are accurate and supported by reliable scholarly sources.

  • AI tools must not be used to fabricate research data, findings, citations, references, or scholarly arguments.

  • Authors must not present AI-generated content as original human intellectual work without appropriate verification, acknowledgment, and disclosure.

b. Human Responsibility and Academic Accountability

Authors remain fully responsible for the accuracy, originality, validity, and integrity of their manuscripts, regardless of whether AI tools have been used.

Authors must:

  • Carefully review and verify all AI-assisted content before manuscript submission.

  • Ensure that the manuscript represents genuine scholarly contributions and independent intellectual work.

  • Verify Qur'anic verses, Hadith texts, translations, interpretations, classical references, and Islamic scholarly opinions against authoritative sources.

  • Ensure that religious arguments and interpretations are presented accurately and in their appropriate scholarly contexts.

  • Maintain the validity and reliability of research methods, data, and conclusions.

  • Take full responsibility for any errors, misleading information, or ethical violations arising from the use of AI.

Generative AI tools cannot be listed as authors or co-authors because they cannot assume responsibility for the accuracy, integrity, and accountability of scholarly publications.

c. Disclosure of AI Use

Authors must disclose the use of Generative AI or AI-assisted technologies when such tools have contributed to the substantive development, analysis, interpretation, or preparation of the manuscript.

The disclosure should include:

  • The name of the AI tool or application used.

  • The purpose and scope of its use.

  • The specific parts of the research or manuscript in which AI was involved.

A suggested declaration is:

Declaration of Generative AI Use

"During the preparation of this manuscript, the author(s) used [name of AI tool] for [specific purpose]. The author(s) subsequently reviewed, verified, and revised the generated content and take full responsibility for the accuracy, originality, and integrity of the published work."

If no Generative AI tools were used, authors may include the following statement:

"The author(s) declare that no Generative AI tools were used in the preparation, writing, analysis, or development of this manuscript."

d. AI in Religious and Scholarly Research Materials

The use of AI in preparing or analyzing religious and scholarly materials requires particular care and verification. Authors must not rely solely on AI-generated content when interpreting or explaining Islamic sources.

Authors are required to:

  • Verify Qur'anic quotations, surah names, verse numbers, and translations using reliable editions and authoritative references.

  • Verify Hadith texts, narrators, sources, and authenticity classifications against recognized Hadith references.

  • Check classical and contemporary Islamic scholarly references against their original sources.

  • Ensure that AI-generated interpretations do not distort the meaning of religious texts or misrepresent scholarly opinions.

  • Clearly distinguish between established religious sources, scholarly interpretations, and the author's own analysis.

e. AI-Generated Images, Data, and Visual Materials

The use of AI to generate, modify, or manipulate research data, photographs, figures, illustrations, tables, or other visual materials must be clearly disclosed.

Authors must not use AI-generated materials to fabricate evidence, misrepresent research findings, or manipulate original research data. Any AI-assisted visual content must comply with applicable copyright, licensing, research ethics, and publication requirements.

4. Policy for Editors

Editors of Ar-Ruhul Ilmi: Journal of Islamic Education and Islamic Thought may use AI-assisted technologies for limited administrative and editorial support, provided that such use does not compromise editorial independence, confidentiality, or publication ethics.

Editors must:

  • Maintain independent and objective editorial judgment.

  • Protect the confidentiality of submitted manuscripts and all unpublished research materials.

  • Avoid uploading confidential manuscripts or identifiable personal information into public AI systems.

  • Verify any AI-assisted information before using it in editorial decisions.

  • Ensure that editorial decisions are based on scholarly quality, originality, relevance, and compliance with publication ethics.

  • Pay particular attention to the accuracy of religious references and scholarly interpretations when assessing manuscripts.

  • Remain fully accountable for all editorial decisions.

AI tools must not independently make final decisions regarding manuscript acceptance, rejection, or publication.

5. Policy for Peer Reviewers

Peer reviewers play an essential role in maintaining the academic quality and integrity of the journal. Therefore, the use of Generative AI during the peer-review process is subject to strict confidentiality and ethical requirements.

Peer reviewers are not permitted to upload, submit, or share submitted manuscripts, unpublished research findings, or confidential review materials with publicly accessible Generative AI tools or external AI platforms.

Furthermore:

  • Reviewers must conduct manuscript evaluations independently and based on their own scholarly expertise.

  • AI tools must not replace reviewers' critical assessment, scholarly judgment, or recommendations.

  • Reviewers must not use AI to generate substantive peer-review reports or editorial recommendations.

  • Reviewers must assess the accuracy and relevance of religious references, interpretations, and scholarly arguments within their areas of expertise.

  • Reviewers must maintain the confidentiality of all manuscripts and related materials.

  • Reviewers remain fully responsible for the accuracy, objectivity, and integrity of their review reports.

Any permitted administrative use of AI must not involve confidential manuscript content or compromise the independence of the review process.

6. Research Integrity and Publication Ethics

The journal does not tolerate the misuse of Generative AI in any form that compromises academic integrity, religious scholarly accuracy, or research credibility.

Prohibited practices include, but are not limited to:

  • Fabricating or falsifying research data, results, or findings using AI.

  • Generating fictitious references, citations, Qur'anic quotations, Hadith texts, or bibliographic information.

  • Presenting AI-generated content as original research without appropriate verification or disclosure.

  • Using AI to produce inaccurate or misleading interpretations of Qur'anic verses, Hadith, or Islamic scholarly sources.

  • Manipulating images, tables, figures, or research evidence in a misleading manner.

  • Submitting AI-generated manuscripts that lack genuine scholarly contributions and critical human oversight.

  • Using AI to plagiarize, reproduce copyrighted materials unlawfully, or misrepresent the originality of a manuscript.

  • Concealing substantial AI involvement when disclosure is required.

Authors, editors, and reviewers must comply with the journal's publication ethics policies and applicable standards of responsible research conduct.

7. Confidentiality and Data Protection

All participants in the publication process must protect confidential information and personal data.

Manuscripts under review, unpublished research findings, personal information, and confidential editorial communications must not be disclosed to or processed through AI systems without appropriate authorization and adequate data protection safeguards.

The journal is committed to maintaining the confidentiality, security, and responsible handling of scholarly materials throughout the editorial and publication processes.

8. Monitoring and Handling of AI Misuse

Ar-Ruhul Ilmi: Journal of Islamic Education and Islamic Thought reserves the right to investigate suspected violations of this policy.

If inappropriate or undisclosed use of Generative AI is identified, the journal may take appropriate actions, including:

  • Requesting clarification or additional information from the authors.

  • Requiring manuscript revisions or corrections.

  • Rejecting manuscripts that violate the journal's ethical requirements.

  • Issuing corrections, expressions of concern, or retractions for published articles, where necessary.

  • Taking further action in accordance with the journal's publication ethics policy.

Any investigation will be conducted fairly and objectively. AI detection tools or automated detection scores will not be considered sufficient evidence of misconduct on their own. Editorial decisions must be based on an assessment of the available evidence and relevant publication ethics standards.

9. Commitment to Responsible AI Use

Ar-Ruhul Ilmi: Journal of Islamic Education and Islamic Thought supports the responsible and ethical use of emerging technologies to advance academic research and scholarly communication.

The journal recognizes that Generative AI can provide valuable assistance in research and academic writing. Nevertheless, human intellectual contribution, critical thinking, scholarly independence, transparency, and accountability must remain central to every stage of scholarly publishing.

In particular, the journal emphasizes that the use of AI in Islamic studies must respect the integrity of religious sources, the accuracy of scholarly interpretations, and the intellectual traditions of Islamic scholarship.

Through this policy, Ar-Ruhul Ilmi is committed to promoting responsible innovation while safeguarding academic integrity, the credibility of Islamic scholarship, and the ethical standards of scientific publication.

This policy may be reviewed and updated periodically to accommodate developments in Generative AI technologies and internationally recognized standards of scholarly publishing.