Generative AI Policies

Al-Hilali: Jurnal Perbankan dan Ekonomi Islam

1. Introduction

Al-Hilali: Jurnal Perbankan dan Ekonomi Islam recognizes that Generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) technologies are increasingly being used in academic research, scholarly writing, data analysis, financial research, and editorial activities. The journal acknowledges that AI-assisted tools can support scholarly work when used responsibly, transparently, and ethically.

This policy establishes guidelines for the responsible use of generative AI in manuscript preparation, editorial management, and peer-review processes. Its primary objective is to safeguard academic integrity, research originality, methodological rigor, financial data accuracy, and the credibility of scholarly publications in Islamic banking and economics.

2. Definition and Scope

Generative AI refers to artificial intelligence technologies capable of generating, modifying, summarizing, translating, or analyzing text, images, data, and other forms of content in response to user instructions. Examples include ChatGPT, Google Gemini, Microsoft Copilot, Claude, and other comparable AI-assisted applications.

This policy applies to all authors, editors, peer reviewers, and other parties involved in the editorial and publication processes of Al-Hilali: Jurnal Perbankan dan Ekonomi Islam.

3. Policy for Authors

Authors may use generative AI tools as supporting instruments in academic research and manuscript preparation, provided that their use does not compromise research originality, scholarly integrity, or the reliability of research findings.

Permitted uses include:

  • Improving grammar, spelling, punctuation, and academic writing style.

  • Assisting with translation and language editing.

  • Supporting literature exploration, summarization, and the organization of research ideas.

  • Assisting with preliminary data processing, classification, and analysis, subject to independent verification.

  • Improving the clarity, structure, and readability of manuscripts.

  • Supporting the exploration of concepts and theoretical frameworks in Islamic banking and Islamic economics.

Authors must comply with the following requirements:

  1. Human Responsibility: Authors remain fully responsible for the accuracy, originality, validity, and integrity of all manuscript content, including material generated or assisted by AI tools.

  2. Disclosure of AI Use: Any substantial use of generative AI in preparing a manuscript must be transparently disclosed. The disclosure should identify the AI tool, its purpose, and the nature of its contribution.

  3. Verification of Information: Authors must independently verify all AI-generated information, references, quotations, financial data, calculations, interpretations, and research findings. AI-generated content must not be accepted without critical examination.

  4. Accuracy of Islamic Financial Principles: When AI tools are used to discuss Islamic banking and economics, authors must carefully verify explanations of Islamic commercial jurisprudence (fiqh al-mu'amalat), Sharia principles, contractual arrangements (akad), and financial transactions. Particular attention must be given to concepts such as riba, gharar, maysir, mudharabah, musyarakah, murabahah, ijarah, salam, and istisna'.

  5. Verification of Islamic Sources: Any AI-generated references to the Qur'an, Hadith, classical Islamic jurisprudence, fatwas, or Sharia standards must be checked against reliable original sources and authoritative scholarly publications. Authors must ensure the accuracy of quotations, translations, interpretations, and attributions.

  6. Financial and Empirical Data Accuracy: Authors must verify all financial statistics, banking indicators, economic calculations, datasets, statistical results, and empirical interpretations against their original sources. AI must not be used to fabricate, manipulate, or misrepresent financial or research data.

  7. References and Citations: Authors must not include fabricated, inaccurate, or unverifiable references generated by AI. Every citation and bibliographic entry must be checked against the original publication or a reliable academic database.

  8. AI as an Author: Generative AI tools cannot be listed as authors or co-authors because they cannot assume responsibility for research, approve the final manuscript, or be held accountable for scholarly content.

  9. Prohibited Practices: Authors must not use AI to fabricate research data, invent references, manipulate statistical findings, misrepresent Sharia principles, produce misleading financial analyses, or conceal substantial AI-generated contributions.

Recommended AI Disclosure Statement

Authors who have used generative AI tools should include a disclosure statement in their manuscript, preferably before the references or in another appropriate section.

Example:

"The author used [name of AI tool] to assist with [specific purpose, such as language editing, translation, data organization, or improving writing clarity]. All AI-assisted content was reviewed, verified, and revised by the author. The author takes full responsibility for the accuracy, originality, and integrity of the entire manuscript."

If no generative AI tools were used, authors may include the following statement:

"The author declares that no generative AI tools were used in the preparation of this manuscript."

4. Policy for Editors

Editors of Al-Hilali: Jurnal Perbankan dan Ekonomi Islam must maintain editorial independence, confidentiality, fairness, and academic integrity throughout the publication process.

Editors may use AI-assisted tools for limited administrative or technical purposes, such as improving communication, organizing editorial information, or supporting routine language-related tasks. However, AI tools must not replace professional editorial judgment.

Editors are required to:

  1. Maintain the confidentiality of submitted manuscripts and all information obtained during editorial handling.

  2. Avoid uploading unpublished manuscripts, confidential research data, or editorial documents to public AI platforms.

  3. Independently assess the originality, relevance, scholarly contribution, methodological quality, and ethical compliance of submitted manuscripts.

  4. Evaluate disclosures of AI use and determine whether such use complies with the journal's ethical standards.

  5. Ensure that AI-generated information does not influence editorial decisions without appropriate human verification.

  6. Pay particular attention to the accuracy of Islamic financial concepts, Sharia compliance claims, financial data, and economic interpretations.

  7. Take appropriate action when suspected AI misuse, fabricated references, inaccurate Sharia explanations, or questionable research practices are identified.

5. Policy for Peer Reviewers

Peer reviewers play an essential role in maintaining the academic quality and credibility of Al-Hilali: Jurnal Perbankan dan Ekonomi Islam. Reviewers must conduct manuscript evaluations independently, objectively, and confidentially.

Reviewers are strictly prohibited from:

  1. Uploading submitted manuscripts, unpublished research data, or confidential review materials to publicly accessible generative AI platforms.

  2. Using generative AI tools to produce substantive peer-review reports or recommendations.

  3. Allowing AI-generated assessments to replace their own scholarly judgment.

  4. Sharing confidential manuscript information with unauthorized individuals or third-party AI services.

Reviewers may use limited AI-assisted tools for general language support, provided that manuscript confidentiality is fully protected and the substantive evaluation remains their own responsibility.

All peer-review reports and recommendations must reflect the reviewers' independent academic expertise and professional judgment, particularly when assessing Islamic financial principles, research methodology, empirical findings, and the relevance of scholarly contributions.

6. Research Integrity and Publication Ethics

Al-Hilali: Jurnal Perbankan dan Ekonomi Islam upholds the principles of honesty, transparency, originality, and accountability in scholarly publishing.

The journal does not tolerate the misuse of generative AI, including:

  • Fabrication or falsification of research data, financial statistics, empirical findings, or references.

  • Plagiarism or the presentation of AI-generated material as original human-authored scholarship without appropriate disclosure.

  • Invented Qur'anic or Hadith quotations, fabricated fatwas, or inaccurate references to Islamic legal and financial sources.

  • Misrepresentation of Islamic banking contracts, Sharia principles, or Islamic economic theories.

  • Manipulation of statistical analyses, financial calculations, or research interpretations.

  • Use of AI to generate misleading arguments, unsupported conclusions, or false claims of Sharia compliance.

Authors are responsible for ensuring that all theoretical explanations, Islamic financial principles, empirical evidence, and scholarly references are accurate and traceable to credible sources.

7. Confidentiality and Data Protection

All parties involved in the publication process must protect the confidentiality of manuscripts, personal information, financial research data, and editorial communications.

Unpublished manuscripts, confidential financial information, research datasets, and editorial materials must not be entered into public AI systems or third-party platforms that may store, process, or reuse submitted content without appropriate authorization.

The journal expects all authors, editors, and reviewers to respect applicable privacy, confidentiality, and data protection principles.

8. Monitoring and Handling of AI Misuse

Al-Hilali: Jurnal Perbankan dan Ekonomi Islam reserves the right to investigate suspected violations of this policy.

If inappropriate or undisclosed AI use is identified, the journal may take appropriate actions, including:

  1. Requesting clarification or additional information from the authors.

  2. Requiring corrections or revisions to the manuscript.

  3. Rejecting a manuscript when serious ethical violations are established.

  4. Retracting a published article if significant misconduct is discovered after publication.

  5. Taking other appropriate measures in accordance with the journal's publication ethics and editorial procedures.

All suspected violations will be evaluated carefully and fairly, taking into consideration the nature, seriousness, and impact of the alleged misconduct.

9. Commitment to Responsible AI Use

Al-Hilali: Jurnal Perbankan dan Ekonomi Islam supports the responsible and transparent use of generative AI as a supplementary tool in scholarly research and publication. Nevertheless, AI technologies must not replace human intellectual contribution, critical thinking, professional expertise, or scholarly accountability.

The journal remains committed to promoting credible scholarship in Islamic banking and economics, preserving the integrity of Sharia-based financial research, and ensuring that every published article meets appropriate standards of originality, accuracy, transparency, and research ethics.